AmTrust Direct is offering 1.55% APY on CDs for three years on deposits of $1,000 at least.
The next best rates are from Doral Bank Direct, Barclays and CIT Bank. At Doral Bank Direct, you can get 1.50% APY on a minimum deposit of $1,000. Barclays pays 1.40% APY on three month certificates of deposit without requiring a minimum deposit. CIT Bank offers 1.42% APY on a deposit of at least $1,000.